In the midst of
the Civil War, as federal troops claimed more territory in the
South, both President Abraham Lincoln and Congress turned their
attention to Reconstruction, the process of reintegrating former
Confederate states into the Union. In December 1863, President
Lincoln announced his Reconstruction plan, which
did not demand that the former Confederate states enfranchise
blacks. A few days later, Republican Congressman James Ashley
of Ohio introduced into the House of Representatives a
Reconstruction bill that did allow black as well as loyal white
men to vote for delegates to state constitutional conventions.
However, the measure was replaced by the
Wade-Davis Bill, which only granted suffrage to loyal
white men. President Lincoln pocket vetoed it in July 1864
because he did not want the congressional policy to replace his
plan.
Meanwhile, on February 22, 1864, the Union oversaw state
elections in Louisiana. On March 12, two leaders of the black
community in New Orleans, Jean-Baptiste Roudanez and Arnold
Bertonneau, met with Lincoln at the White House and urged the
president to enfranchise their city’s black men. They argued
that the federal government had legitimate power over voting
qualifications, and that enfranchising freedmen and ex-slaves
was the only way that the Union could secure political stability
in the South. Although President Lincoln did not agree that the
federal government could supercede state authority over voting
regulations, two days later he wrote privately to Louisiana’s
new governor, Michael Hahn, suggesting that he consider granting
suffrage to “some of the colored people … for instance, the very
intelligent, and especially those who have fought gallantly in
our ranks.”
Roudanez and Bertonneau also met
with other Republican leaders, including Senator Charles Sumner
of Massachusetts, who on March 15
introduced
into Congress a petition from 1000 Louisiana blacks calling for
the right to vote. Governor Hahn was not able to convince
delegates to grant suffrage to black men in the proposed state
constitution, although he was able to see the legislature
authorized to do so.
In December 1864, Congressman Ashley again introduced a
Reconstruction bill, which required former Confederate states to
enfranchise black men. Unable to gain sufficient support, he
amended the bill to require voter registration of loyal
white men only, while arguing that black soldiers should be
enfranchised by the new state constitutions in Louisiana,
Arkansas, and Tennessee (Confederate states then under
Union
control). Harper’s Weekly editor George William Curtis
concluded that Ashley’s bill was defeated by a
combination of those claiming it violated states’ rights and
those disappointed that it did not enfranchise black men.
On April 11, 1865, two days after Confederate General Robert
E. Lee surrendered at Appomattox and four days before his death,
President Lincoln explained publicly to a crowd gathered on the
White House lawn what he had previously told then-Governor Hahn
in private concerning the enfranchisement of black men. Lincoln
remarked that he would “prefer that it [the franchise] were now
conferred on the very intelligent, and on those who serve our
cause as soldiers.” Nevertheless, the president urged Congress
to recognize Louisiana’s new state government even if it did not
yet allow black men to vote. “Concede that the new government
of Louisiana is only to what it should be as the egg is to the
fowl, we shall sooner have the fowl by hatching the egg than by
smashing it.” He emphasized the importance of Louisiana to the
ratification of the proposed Thirteenth Amendment, which aimed
to abolish slavery. |